How to fix the wild card and keep the baseball playoffs fair

How to fix the wild card and keep the baseball playoffs fair
Joel Sherman

Thank you, new readers here on Sports+ for taking a spin with me on one of my obsessions — and not one of those good obsessions like playing golf or collecting vintage trading cards.

No, this one is about the wild-card game. And my lingering concerns about not just fairness — though certainly fairness is central to this — but about the integrity of the 162-game season.

I am pretty sure that my suggested rule change is never going to be implemented because, obviously, it is not going to be in place in 2021, and there could be a new playoff system beginning next year because the collective bargaining agreement is 10 weeks from expiration.

But if the playoff system is going to stay 10-teams tight, which means two wild cards in each league, then what I would like to see is this: If the top-seeded wild card finished five or more games better than the lower seeded wild card, then rather than playing just a sudden-death game (as it is now), they would play essentially a best-of-two series in the higher seed’s home stadium in which the higher seed would have to win just once while the lower seed wins twice.